Thursday Boots Review 2023 - You’re Premium Leather Boot With Fair Price

If you are in the market for handcrafted, high-quality leather or suede boots at fair pricing, you have very few options at your disposal. This is because such boots mainly cost well over $300. However, Thursday Boots is out to change this.

We will review the brand and some of their boots in our Thursday Boots review to help you decide whether they are worth purchasing, or not.

Overview & Highlights

Let’s get an overview of the brand and some highlights.

About Thursday Boots?

Founded in 2014 by Nolan Walsh and Connor Wilson, Thursday Boots is a New York-based shoe company selling men’s and women’s footwear.

The truth is that the founders were unhappy with the boots in the market and decided they would create a brand that sells enduring, versatile boots made with quality materials at fair prices.

Consequently, they become known for their handcrafted shoes and boots. But, they also sell apparel and accessories like wallets, belts, bags, socks, and more.

In a nutshell, they offer clean and classic designs, and use high-quality materials for all their products.

Who Is it best for?

Thursday Boots footwear is for anyone who appreciates footwear made with high-quality materials and sold at fair prices.

This brand understands that everyone has busy lives, where they need the right shoes and products to help accomplish each day with comfort and versatile style.

And since Thursday Boots works only with companies that share their high ethical standards and passion for a sustainable environment, it makes them a good option for conscious consumers.

Why ‘Thursday’?

Simply because “Thursday” is the unofficial intro into the weekend, and yet it’s officially a workday too.

In essence, the name signifies the brand’s versatility and its products that are great for work and pleasure.

Where can we buy them?

You can buy Thursday Boots footwear and products at their main retail store in Flatiron. You can also buy them online from their official website or at Amazon.

How big is the network?

While the brand started from a simple idea of selling quality and enduring boots at fair prices, they have since grown throughout the nation and many countries across the globe.

That said, you’ll find their products being worn across fifty states and around sixty countries, which is incredible.

What is it made of?

Thursday Boots footwear and products are made with high-quality materials like

• premium suede
• weatherproof suede
• horween leather
• Thursday veg-chrome tannage
• and premium leather that ages beautifully.

They also use high-quality padded midsoles, leather linings, and arch support for superior comfort.

The brand ensures that they maintain such quality materials throughout their footwear and product lines.

Thursday Boots Customer Support

Our experience proved that Thursday Boots’ customer support is friendly and helpful. Furthermore, they are responsive, offer comprehensive guidance, and have complete knowledge of any questions you may have.

Consequently, you can reach them through their website, email, and phone. Here are their customer support contact details:

• You can fill out a web form through their official site.
• You can also email them at [email protected].
• Use the live chat support.
• Or, just give them a ring at +1 866-475-9104.

However, on their site, you can also find a complete FAQs section that can answer a good number of questions you may have.

Features & Factors

In this section, we will discuss some of Thursday Boots’ key features and factors, things like Thursday Boots quality, materials, comfort, colors, and more.

• Quality

Thursday Boots quality is perhaps their most significant promise and selling point simultaneously. Especially because of the surprisingly low market prices.

The comfort, durability, and high-quality materials you get with their handcrafted boots are rare to find in today’s market.

While most brands typically cut corners to save costs, Thursday Boots maintains quality. And how is this done? By investing in high-quality materials selection for their footwear. Ultimately, their products are designed and tested meticulously, made from premium leather and including durable laces.

Moreover, all their footwear is expertly handcrafted by some of the best artisans.

• Material/Type of Leather Used

As mentioned, Thursday Boots prides itself on quality materials, and they work with world-class partners, including top suppliers, to provide you with the best of the best. They mostly use cow leather for their footwear, and it is tested to age well over time.

Thursday Boots’ waterproof suede is another quality material that is very popular among their customers.

Here are the premium, high-quality leather and suede materials you’ll find with Thursday Boots:

• Horween Leather

Considered the golden standard of quality leather made in the States, Horween Leather provides Thursday Boots with an exceptional generations-old tannage such as the Natural Chromexcel.

• Thursday Chrome Leather

A proprietary leather from Thursday Boots, the Thursday Chrome is a double-tanned leather that offers the durability of a veg tan. It ages well and is produced at the award-winning LeFarc tannery.

• WeatherSafe Suede

This is Thursday Boots’ waterproof and suede material. It comprises a collection of WeatherSafe suede that features a solution of hydrophobic and waterproof compounds. They call it “suede with an upgrade” because it can stop water from going through the leather.

• Rugged and Resilient

These non-shiny (true matte) leathers are sourced from Tier 1 USA cattle hides, which means it ages amazingly and looks better year on year.

• Style & Versatility

When it comes to style and versatility, Thursday Boots delivers! They offer immense versatility, made evident by their choice of the brand name. Their products are designed to be worn at work and parties alike — The style is primarily classic and functional.

Thursday Boots believes in clean, timeless, and handcrafted designs. This is why they have no external branding because they want to let the extraordinary craftsmanship,well-thought design, and top-notch materials speak for their style.

• Colors

As you would expect from classic leather style footwear, Thursday Boots have limited colors. However, they make the most of it by offering a more comprehensive color range than most other leather product brands.

Their colors include various shades of brown and black, including Black Matte, Dusty, Walnut, Tobacco, Saddlewood, Shadow Gray, Sandstone, Terracotta, Chocolate, Burnt Ginger, Cognac, Dark Olive, Burnt Copper, and more.

• Comfort, Fit & Sizing

So, how do Thursday Boots fit? For the most part, they fit exactly as you would expect classic boots and shoes to fit. Their high-quality materials, padding, and insoles make them very comfortable while retaining the right size and fit.

However, our experience and most of their customers tells us that Thursday Boots tend to make their footwear slightly slimmer than most competitors. This is perhaps on purpose so customers can break into their boots and shoes after a couple of wears for the perfect fit.

They recommend a half size down for the leather to mold to a comfortable fit. They also suggest that women have exact size boots or half a size larger. Their sizes are the exact fit of the majority of the American population. Nevertheless, they offer most footwear in standard or wide widths. Therefore, finding your fit won’t be a problem.

Is Thursday’s Footwear Waterproof/Water-Resistant?

Yes, Thursday Boots’ waterproof options come from their collections that use their WaterSafe Suede in the construction. This is why water won’t pass through the leather.

How Does It Work?

Here, we will talk about our selection of some of the best boots that Thursday Boots has to offer, how you should use them, and more.

How To Use It?

The high-quality materials, designs, and handcrafted construction mean that you can use Thursday Boots as you please. Hence, versatility and comfort are never out of style. You can wear them practically anywhere, whether to work, a party, or even an outdoor adventure; these boots will tackle the task.

Anyway, most customers prefer to pair them with a Thursday Boots outfit for a complete look.

What Is Shoe Care?

In a nutshell, shoe care is vital when owning leather/suede boots. And if you weren’t aware of that or didn’t know how to properly take care of them, no worries. Thursday Boots has a dedicated section on their official site with a straightforward guide on how to properly handle leather/suede shoes/boots.

And that’s not all. Thursday Boots also offer a rich line of shoe care products that allow you to use and maintain their footwear for longer.

It includes products like

• shoe cleaners,
• suede brushes,
• leather cleaners,
• balms,
• creams,
• conditioners,
• fresheners,
• waterproofing sprays, and more.

This line of products also includes accessories like various laces, shoe horns, and shoe/boot trees. Thursday Boots ensures that they provide all the necessary things you may need to make your Thursday Boots last a lifetime.

What Are the Best Picks of Thursday Boots?

Here is our selection of the best boots Thursday Boots offers for men and women:

• Captain Men’s Boots

The Captain offers a classic, clean look and finishes made from premium leather. The leather material of this boot is designed to age well as you wear it over time. Additionally, it has a cap-toe, short heel, and full-length laces for a comfortable fit.

The Captain men’s boots are constructed with Thursday Boots waterproof materials making them a great option to wear in any season. In addition, it is completely lined with a leather interior, making it comfortable for all-day’s wear.

You get a vast array of color options (Golden Brown, Arizona Adobe, Burnt Coffee, Old English, etc.) that include premium suede or leather finishes. This consists of the “Rugged & Resilient” options with matte leather uppers sourced exclusively from the highest-quality, Tier 1 USA cattle hides.

• Captain Women’s Boots

The Thursday Boots Women’s Captain offers the same leather quality as the men’s boots, with the same features. These boots are not very different from the men’s Captain in design, which means they are not excessively feminine and provide a casual look.

Consequently, there is a decent variety of options to choose from, even if the color choices are not abundant. The Captain is a comfortable, everyday lace-up boot for women to get them through their entire day.

There is a solid variety of colors to choose from, depending on your choice of suede or leather finish, including Matte Black, Tobacco, Brandy, Mocha, Whiskey, Black Coffee, Natural, Dark Olive Suede, and many more.

• The President Men’s Boots

The President men’s boots offer a similar look and feel to the Captain with subtle design changes that make them feel more premium. The boot has a comfortable full glove leather interior lining and cork-bed midsole, while the premium flat waxed cotton laces make for a fresh and stylish look.

The Goodyear Welt construction provides water resistance and also makes them fully re-soleable. Additionally, the studded rubber outsoles offer added grip on various surfaces, whereas the leather upper gives a gorgeous finish, which looks even better over time.

• The Knockout Women’s Boot

The Thursday Boots Women‘s Knockout is a high-heeled Chelsea shoe that nicely defines form + function. The inner is completely lined with supple leather for comfort, and the Poron Antimicrobial Shock Absorbing Insoles form to your feet over time, only to add to that comfort.

The flexible elastic goring makes for easy, slip-on wearing and the custom-developed rubber outsoles give the boot outstanding durability and traction. This Thursday Boots’ heel height is 2.75-inches, coupled with the 5-inch shaft, making it versatile to wear in any weather, be it snow, sun, or rain.

Since the styling is classic it gives you the confidence to wear them wherever you please, making it one of the best boots for women from this brand.

• The Duke Men’s Boots

The Duke comes in two options, high-quality suede or hand-finished, full-grain leather, depending on the color you choose. It is a versatile Chelsea boot for men that can be dressed up or down and comes highly recommended by Thursday Boots customers and other men’s style publishers (Esquire, Men’s Journal, etc.).

It has the same comfort and construction features as the Knockout women’s boots, except for the custom outsoles replaced by the Goodyear Welt construction for longevity, water resistance, and re-soleability. Additionally, this is a feature present in all Chelsea men’s boots from this brand.

While the WeatherSafe suede options of the Duke are great, we recommend the full-grain leather uppers because of how well they age over time. Hence, the styling is minimal, and the material speaks for itself. We think this is a men’s boot that truly encompasses the essence of Thursday Boots, which is precisely why it is one of our best picks.

Pricing

This section will discuss the pricing of Thursday Boots and relevant aspects like shipping, promotions, and more.

How much does it cost?

On average, Thursday Boots cost under $200, which is a fair price for the handcrafted construction and high-quality materials you get.

Nevertheless, here is a complete price list of their boots, as it currently stands at the time of writing this Thursday Boots Review.

Thursday Boots Men’s Pricing

• Captain – $190
• The President – $199
• The Casa Moto Racer – $235
• The Cavalier – $190
• The Legend – $199
• The Diplomat – $199
• The Explorer – $249
• The Duke – $199
• The Major – $199
• The Scout – $149
• The Cadet – $190
• The Wingtip – $235
• The Harness – $199
• The Commander – $249
• Vanguard – $265
• Logger – $285
  

Thursday Boots Women‘s Pricing

• Captain – $190
• The Duchess – $160
• The Knockout – $168
• The Tempo – $168
• The Soho – $195
• The Combat – $180
• The Explorer – $249
• The Legend – $160
• The Downtown – $140
• The Highline – $180
• The Duchess Bootie – $160
• The Rebel – $190
• The Indio – $180
• Heartbreaker – $195
• The Icon – $180
• The Tempest – $235
• The Raider – $180
  

With so many boots, color options, material choices, and even upscale materials, it is hard to believe that Thursday Boots started with only a handful of options in basic colors. Plus, they are constantly expanding, and it wouldn’t be surprising to see a few more options by next year.

Shipping Policy

Thursday Boots offers shipping in the contiguous U.S. and internationally. Although they have shipped to 100+ international countries, timing and rates may vary from location to location.

Orders with expedited shipping made after 2 pm ET are not shipped the same day. Moreover, Thursday Boots doesn’t ship orders on Saturdays, Sundays, or significant American holidays. Unfortunately, international shipping costs aren’t covered by Thursday Boots.

• Does it provide free shipping?

Yes, Thursday Boots offers free shipping on $50+ orders across the contiguous U.S. Within this region, you can also get free return shipping on $80+ items, like footwear, jackets, bags, and belts.

Moreover, international shipping is free for the UK, Germany, and Canada for $100+ orders.

What is the Return Policy?

If you order the wrong size or find any issues with your Thursday Boots, you can exchange or return them for free within the contiguous U.S. However, to return the items, you can’t wear or damage them, and the item must be without any creases or wear on soles.

Moreover, you must return the item in its original packing, and the return request must be done within 30 days of delivery.

You must remember that Thursday Boots have the right to refuse returns that don’t meet the criteria mentioned above. What’s more, they also have the right to refuse free shipping for any customer returns.

Note: Thursday Seconds and any items purchased as final sale are not eligible for returns or exchanges.

Any Discounts/ Promotions?

Thursday Boots has built their reputation on fair, honest pricing, which is why they don’t offer any discounts or promotions. Some of you might be surprised by their policy, but this shouldn’t come as a surprise given how affordable their footwear is compared to similar quality competitors.

However, they often have lightly used pairs or factory seconds (Thursday Seconds) at hand, which you can get at a discount by emailing them the details of the size and style of boot you are looking for. If they have something that meets your requirement, they will try to accommodate your request.

Do they provide any warranty on their products?

Currently, Thursday Boots doesn’t offer any warranty on their products.

Pros & Cons

Let’s discuss some pros and cons of Thursday Boots

Pros:

• Handcrafted footwear with high-quality materials at fair pricing.
• Wide variety of footwear styles, finishes, sizes, and colors for men and women.
• A good range of high-quality apparel and accessories to complement their footwear.
• Easy-to-use and navigate website, with a comprehensive FAQs section.
• Free shipping on domestic and (some) international orders with easy returns

Cons:

• No promotions or discounts on retail items.
• No footwear options for kids.

Customer Reviews & Ratings

We look at hundreds of consumer reviews and ratings to give you an unbiased perspective, as with all our reviews. We only choose the most trusted sources like BBB and Trustpilot for our reviews and ratings.

Consumer Reviews

While the Thursday Boots website boasts hundreds of excellent consumer reviews, we always want to look outside of what the brand shows as social proof. After much research, we discovered that consumers love the products and services. However, there are some issues regarding shipping and returns.

Nevertheless, every product was praised, but some customers faced problems with shipping and exchanges, while a handful faced rejected returns. As always, there were some exceptions as well. For instance, some customers said they didn’t like the quality or crafting of their Thursday Boots.

Still, the overall tone of consumer reviews and ratings was good, with product quality and pricing being the standout features most people appreciated.

Here are some positive and negative reviews to give you a better idea.

Positive Customer Reviews

• crazymouse798 rated Thursday Boots with 5/5 stars, and this is the comment that was left alongside:

“Fantastic boots! Great customer experience. Ordered two sizes to see which one was better, returned the one that didn’t through happy returns, and it was a very smooth experience. The boots I kept are awesome. I might even buy a second pair in a different color 🙂 Keep it up!”

(Source: Worthepenny)

• Karen E. gave them 5/5 rating, and this is what she had to say about their product:

“Thursday Boot Customer Experience

Happy with my purchase (Black Legend Boot) despite reading the negative reviews on this site. Very good customer service. I would advise using the fit tool on the website when ordering. Very comfortable boot. My experience was closer to that of the average rating (4.6) on Google.”

(Source: Trustpilot)

• Crystal Suggs Hunley shared her experience with Thursday Boot’s products, and this is what she had to say about them:

“Excellent quality boots and customer service! I purchased the black dreamer while visiting NYC a couple of weeks ago. I bought my normal size and they fit perfect. All of the sales reps were very knowledgeable, courteous and quick to respond. They shipped my boots to my home for free and I received them within a week. I have worn the boots a few times already and love them. Very comfortable! Highly recommend!

My friend accidentally forgot her shopping bag in the store during our visit and we didn’t realize it till the following day. We called and fortunately they had found the bag. The CS Representative was eager to help and shipped the package to us since we had already left the city. 10/10”

(Source: Thursday Boots Official Facebook Page)

Negative Customer Reviews

• Steve MacCallum rated it with 1/5 stars, and this is his experience with the brand:

”Pulled the curtain back on Thursday Boot

Was ecstatic to find your company, made my first purchase the Cavalier Chelsea, great boot great price. My wife tried to purchase s Christmas present, a racer jacket and her order has been a complete debacle and nobody at Thursday Boot wants to take ownership and correct the problem, very disappointed, shame.”

(Source: Trustpilot)

• Ask also rated Thursday Boots with 1/5 stars and this is the experience shared on Trustpilot:

“I used to like Thursday boots. However, in the last couple of years, I purchased about 50 -60 plus pairs and had returned about 10 pairs due to inconsistent sizing. And now they won’t let me return anymore, stating that I return too much? I asked them to explain, and the answer I got was that they had already sent me an email – which basically said I returned too much. Email was sent by Carlo. Carlo made no sense. I purchased 50 pairs which cost approximately $12,000 and returned approximately ten pairs worth approximately $2,000. I don’t get it. I know it’s silly, but I feel offended. I was a loyal customer, and that is how they treated me. I hope management is aware of this.”

(Source: Trustpilot)

Customer Ratings

Customer ratings were not the best for Thursday Boots. However, they weren’t entirely bad either. Here’s a closer look at their rating according to several rating sites.

* Thursday Boots have no accreditation from the BBB. However, they do have a C+ grade rating.

Trustpilot averaged their customer ratings at 2.8 stars, slightly below average. Similarly, BBB rated them at C+, which is also average.

However, you must note that Thursday Boots is not accredited by BBB, adding to their lower rating than competitors.

Alternatives

This section will compare Thursday Boots with some competitors to show you what other options are available in the market and whether they are worthy. Our choice for that purpose are the following brands: Tecovas, Jack Erwin, and Beckett Simonon.

Thursday Boots vs. Tecovas

Tecovas is a footwear brand that specializes in handmade suede and leather cowboy boots. They were founded the same year (2014) as Thursday Boots started. Whatsmore, they offer quality footwear at similar pricing, making them the perfect competitor.

However, their boots are entirely focused on cowboy and ranch styling, making them less versatile. Moreover, they offer plenty more physical stores than just one from Thursday Boots. Overall, both these brands offer excellent quality boots but cater to slightly different audiences.

If you want versatile boots for everyday wear, Thursday is better option. Whereas if you like ranch wear and cowboy boots, you should opt for Tecovas.

Thursday Boots vs. Jack Erwin

Another New York-based brand that offers quality footwear, Jack Erwin, was founded in 2013. They have more or less similar pricing, making them a direct competitor.

However, Jack Erwin offers clean, versatile boots that are crafted with simplicity and function in mind. They have some great pairs of Chelsea boots and provide other forms of footwear (loafers, drivers, boat shoes, slippers, sneakers, formal shoes, etc.)

Ultimately, as a footwear brand, Jack Erwin’s are good. But when it comes to boots, Thursday Boots greatly outnumbers them in style, color, and material options.

Thursday Boots vs. Beckett Simonon

Founded in 2011, Beckett Simonon offers some excellent quality, handcrafted footwear designed for longevity. In addition, they offer exquisite quality suede and leather boots that are competitively priced (all boots cost under $250).

While they are slightly more pricey than the average Thursday Boots, they also offer free shipping, returns, and exchanges in the contiguous U.S., the same as Thursday Boots. But, unlike Thursday Boots, they have a 60-day money-back guarantee and a 1-year warranty against manufacturing or material defects.

Ultimately, since they offer classic and versatile styling, you may be compelled to opt for Beckett Simonon for the quality, longevity, added services, and warranty if you don’t mind paying a little extra.

The Wrap Up

Our overall experience with Thursday Boots has been excellent. They offer incredibly attractive options at even more attractive pricing. Their quality of boots is perhaps only surpassed by their superb marketing efforts, which have seen them grow so big over the years.

They keep adding more styles and options, which means we will likely see a lot more from them in the coming years. But, for now, their website is great and functional, their products even more fantastic. Moreover, their pricing is fair, making them an ideal option when you need versatile, high-quality, handcrafted boots.

While some customers are not happy with their shipping and returns, and their ratings are just average, our research for this Thursday Boots review has been a pleasant experience.

Is Thursday Boots worth it?

Yes, Thursday Boots is worth trying at least once. You may be surprised by the quality of the product at this price range. Not to mention that their styling and function are versatile enough that you can make good use of any pair you order.

This is why we would recommend trying them out at least once, even if it is simply to form your opinion about the brand and their products. And, then again, why not allow your feet to wear one of the best boots on today’s market.